Dovetail vs taxizedb

taxizedb queries taxonomic databases locally rather than through rate-limited web APIs, which is what makes it usable for millions of name lookups. Version 0.2.0 established the current design: every source stored as SQLite, no credentials or ports needed, plus name-to-ID mapping functions and ports of the core taxize verbs. The most recent release changes how those databases arrive — instead of downloading a preprocessed SQLite file from the cloud, db_download_*() now fetches raw data and converts it locally for every source, because the cloud path kept breaking.

The package is trading convenience for independence. Each release removes another thing that has to be working elsewhere for the package to function: hosted database preparation is gone, and where a provider disappears the package documents it rather than pretending otherwise — db_download_tpl() is now defunct because The Plant List no longer exists, though previously downloaded copies still query fine. Release cadence is slow, with multi-year gaps and a maintainer handover in 2023.

Expect further releases to track data sources appearing and disappearing rather than adding features, since that has driven every recent change. Local conversion also shifts cost onto users, so build time and memory for the larger sources are the plausible next thing to need attention.