← Back to home
Comparison · Collab

BookStack vs Shortcut

Side-by-side trajectory, velocity, and editorial themes.

B
BookStack
COLLAB
1.3

BookStack opened a real theme extension surface, then spent six weeks patching CVEs.

◆ Current state

BookStack shipped v26.03 in mid-March 2026 with a meaningful new theme module system and several theme events (page render, pre-save, OIDC URL customization) — the first time the project's customization surface has had real extension points rather than just template overrides. The next six weeks were almost entirely security work: four security-marked patch releases (v25.12.9, v26.03.1, v26.03.2, v26.03.4) addressing role-escalation via registration, hidden content leaking through markdown exports, style-code injection in revision diffs, and attachment/webhook URL validation gaps. Multiple researchers credited per release.

◆ Where it's heading

The arc is 'open up the platform, then defend it' — adding extension points was the v26.03 push, and the subsequent CVE volume reads as a coordinated audit response (often two researchers credited per advisory, suggesting public attention from pen-testers). The 25.12.x line is also still being patched in parallel, indicating the team is supporting both branches rather than forcing rapid upgrades.

◆ Prediction

Expect another v26.03.x patch release if the audit cycle isn't complete, then a return to feature work — likely more theme-event coverage and exposing more lifecycle hooks to match what the new module system can attach to. The dual-branch maintenance pattern probably continues until v25.12 hits its support cutoff.

Shortcut logo
Shortcut
COLLABPM
7.5

Shortcut redesigns its API for AI agents and pushes Korey beyond its own walls.

◆ Current state

Shortcut is making concrete bets on agent-based work. API v4 entered alpha on May 12 with explicit framing around expanded capabilities and 'agent compatibility' — a positioning shift, not just a version bump. Their in-house AI assistant Korey is expanding outward: right-click access in February, then a dedicated Chrome extension in April that runs on any webpage. Around the strategic work, smaller improvements (Teams on Roadmap, March's SLA Alerts) keep shipping, alongside feed-noise from brand-guide pages being scraped as if they were releases.

◆ Where it's heading

Shortcut is positioning itself as the project-management surface that AI agents naturally operate against, not just a PM tool with AI features bolted on. Korey is being pushed from in-app helper toward general-purpose web assistant; the API is being redesigned with external agent consumers in mind. That's a coherent strategic stance the bigger PM players — Jira, Linear, Asana — have not yet made as explicitly. Underlying release cadence stays steady, suggesting these are strategic plays, not panicked pivots.

◆ Prediction

Expect API v4 to surface MCP-style tooling endpoints and structured action surfaces aimed squarely at agent frameworks. Korey's Chrome extension is likely a stepping stone toward a 'Korey anywhere' positioning — deeper integrations with browser, email, and calendar are the natural next dominoes.

See more alternatives to BookStack
See more alternatives to Shortcut